In the world of organizational development, we are currently suffering from a plague of “experts” who have forgotten, or perhaps never knew, how the adult brain actually works. We’ve all sat through it: the agonizing slide decks, the drone of a “Sage on the Stage” (the worst: the despair of some long-dead first-line supervisor / Chief / Sheriff / Director who has been exhumed by POST and sent to the front of the room to preach about a world that no longer exists) … and the overwhelming sense that we are being talked at rather than provided with developmental opportunities.
The hard truth? Having a high-level resume or a litany of post-nominal initials doesn’t make you a high-level teacher. There is a massive, structural gap between subject matter expertise and andragogy … the specific art and science of helping adults learn.
Data Dumps
Too many so-called instructors treat adult education like a high school lecture hall. They assume that if they simply dump their vast knowledge into the room, the students will absorb it by osmosis. They prioritize their own perceived brilliance over the student’s actual transformation.
Adult learners are not empty vessels. They’re not broken. They come to the table with a lifetime of experience, a limited amount of time, and a “need to know” that is strictly tied to immediate, real-world application. When an instructor ignores these drivers, the learning doesn’t just fail to stick; it breeds resentment. If you focus on the what … the dry data, the academic charts … without ever touching the why or the how, you aren’t creating a learning environment; you’re just talking. You’re not leading; you’re just on a walk.
Learning is a Partnership
However, we must be careful not to place the entire burden of transformation on the instructor. Education is not a spectator sport. Even the most gifted inspirationalist cannot “install” wisdom into a passive mind.
The student has a profound obligation in this exchange: the responsibility of intent. If a participant enters the room (or the Zoom call) with their arms crossed, waiting to be entertained or “fixed,” the process is dead on arrival. Real growth requires a student who is willing to be uncomfortable, to admit (to themselves more than to anyone else) what they don’t know, to freely share their opinions, and to actively bridge the gap between a classroom concept and their own daily reality. An instructor can provide the map, but the student must be the one to walk the path.
Pro Tip to Students: Acting like a Purposeful Adult is helpful. WANT to be there. Do not show up at training workshops asking, “What is this training about? My supervisor sent me.” Try sitting in the front of the room rather than hiding in the back row. Bring a pencil and notepad or equivalent; take notes. Ask clarifying questions. Stop surfing the net when you should be participating. Speak up if you have an opinion; your opinions are important. Take information back to your organization and share it with others.
From Speaker to Guidant
Adult training should be a facilitated experience of discovery, not a one-way transmission of facts. It requires a Purposeful Adult who understands that their role is to be a Guidant, someone who designs the “Aha!” moments for the student rather than just narrating their own CV. I have witnessed too many of those long-winded self-introductions. (Pro Tip: you got the job; stop applying.)
Without a grasp of how the adult brain builds neural pathways through active recall and psychological safety, these trainers are really just speakers. They might entertain or inform for an hour, but they don’t truly inspire behavioral change. And in the world of organizational culture, if behavior doesn’t change, training becomes simply a checkbox on a form and a certificate acknowledging that the student was at or near where the Self-Important Instructor may or may not have said something useful.
Four Principles of The Guidant Path
If we want actually to impact the culture of our organizations, we have to demand more from our education, and from ourselves. We have to move toward a model that respects the adult learner’s reality:
- Create A Learning Organization Rather Than A Trained Organization. This must be woven into the fabric of an organization’s culture. Trained organizations tend to be static, by-the-book, lockstep, policy-worshipping entities wherein every mistake is a cause for non-adult people of rank and title to lose their minds and then write blanket policies to punish everyone. Learning organizations tend to be much more flexible, adapt rapidly to environmental changes, and are committed to innovation and long-range planning; all mistakes are coaching and learning opportunities. Pro Tip: A culture centered around pure training tends to produce the trained. A culture centered around the value of learning will produce the future of your industry.
- Context Over Content: If a student can’t use a concept in their “leadership laboratory” … their next 1:1 or team huddle … it’s just background noise.
- Effort Over Ease: Real learning challenges our complacency. We need retrieval exercises, not just passive watching. If it doesn’t challenge the brain to recall the info, the brain won’t store it.
- Safety Over Status: High-performance learning requires an environment where it is safe to fail. If the instructor is more concerned with being the smartest person in the room than creating a safe space for growth, the room … and whatever information was imparted … stays dormant.
It’s time to stop settling for “instructors” and start looking for guides. The path to a better culture isn’t paved with more data; it’s paved with a true understanding of otherness.
Listen more than you talk; ask more than you tell. Those go a long way toward that understanding.
If you have a problem you’d like to discuss in a confidential, no-obligation Zoom visit, you can self-schedule it by clicking on this button:
Author’s Note: The content provided in this article is designed exclusively for educational and informational purposes, reflecting opinions shaped by decades of leadership training and organizational consulting experience. It should never be interpreted as formal professional advice. By reading or engaging with this material, you acknowledge that no professional-client relationship is established and that these insights do not substitute for tailored guidance from a qualified professional familiar with your specific circumstances. Consequently, readers are strongly advised to seek independent counsel from licensed legal, financial, medical, or other appropriate advisors before implementing any strategies or making decisions based on these perspectives. Ultimately, you assume full personal responsibility for any actions you choose to take or omit as a result of reading this material, releasing the author and publisher from any liability for outcomes arising from your reliance on the text.
